Different for difference sake

Experience has taught me that I should pay attention to trends when they start to pop up in a few different places at once. One such trend has recently stuck its head above my parapet.

I was at a Bord Bia talk on the future of Irish food and drink brands earlier this month and Tim Mobsy (recently retired Chairman of Kellogg Europe) made a very compelling case about the business danger of over fragmenting a market – thus losing focus and customer interest, cannibalisation etc.

Last week, someone waxed so lyrically about the virtues of a book called Different by a Harvard professor Youngme Moon that I have now just finished reading it (an aside…. this was my first ebook – pros and cons of same in later blog).

It is a great read. Her thesis is quite damning with regards to how companies in attempting to improve/augment their brands have created a world where most of the differences are now meaningless. I can think of countless markets where this is the case.

She challenges the reader to think less about focusing on the weakness of a brand (and getting it to the same place as its competition) but instead to focus on its strengths and thus create meaningful gaps between it and its competition. The book is littered with examples of brands (the good and the bad) striving for competitive advantage.

To succeed she challenges marketers to forget the ‘rules’ they have learnt. Like Malcolm Gladwell she believes we should look at the ‘Outliers’, the brands who are doing things differently, not to copy them but to learn from the journey they have taken.

Margaret

Posted in Advertising, Branding, Digital, Interesting thoughts, Planning, Rant | Leave a comment

..are we really time poor?

I saw this comment in the Telegraph today – no wonder we don’t have time anymore

“Terrifying data download of the day: A US study has shown that everyone is bombarded with enough data everyday to fill 174 newspapers. And, even more worryingly, the average person (well those on email, mobile, tweeting and using a bit of Facebook) is apparently producing six newspapers worth of information each day. In 1986 we produced just 2.5 pages a day.”

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Dry Well or Well Timed?

When is the right time to re-make an old ad? In fact, is there ever a right time?

We’ve seen old ads put back on air time and time again, especially around Christmas, but rarely do you see a classic completely remixed for a modern audience.

The ad above is one such example. For those of you under 30 here’s the original:

From the moment it first aired it was an instant classic and to this day it regularly appears on any “Best ads” lists alongside Hamlet, Smash, Hovis and Guinness Surfer.

But why remake it?

Is it a well timed piece of nostalgia designed to keep the brand relevant. Demonstrating to traditional phone book users that despite new technology The Yellow Pages still has a place in our lives?

Or is it trying to attract a younger audience who’ve grown up with google searches, in which case why bother remixing an ad that they never seen in the first place?

It’s probably a bit of both in truth.

Part of me likes the idea that ads are such an important part of popular culture that they could warrant a remake but another part of me wants to leave the originals alone. Leave them as the classics they are.

The notion of a remake constantly divides opinion. Some people love the new MINI or Beetle for example and see them as an homage to a great design while others believe its just lazy car makers trying to cash in on a classic’s heritage.

When it comes to movies the popular opinion seems to be that remakes are a bad idea – Stallone in Get Carter for example – but there are always exceptions and this year’s True Grit, nominated for 10 Oscars, would seem destined to be one of them.

Will Day V Lately’s Pulse and Thunder ever complete with Fly Fishing by J.R. Hartley?

Not for me. I think Day V is merely a squatter in J.R. house.

Patrick

Posted in Advertising, Branding, Creative, Planning | Leave a comment

The Waiting Game


When I was 13, I asked a girl to go out with me. It was on the basketball court in school, at little break. I was terrified, plucking every bit of courage I had to ask the question. I was hopeful she’d say yes, but ready for rejection. What I wasn’t prepared for, was the answer I got.

“I’ll think about it”

Suddenly I was thrown into a state of flux. Were we going out or not? I didn’t know whether to be happy or sad. It occurred to me that, until I found out the answer, I was trapped. I couldn’t make any plans with my friends and I certainly couldn’t ask anyone else out. It wasn’t good news or bad news. It was even worse. It was no news.

In many ways, it’s the same with the pitching process. You work for weeks, pouring your heart and soul (and money and effort) into a pitch. You believe that your work both answers the client’s brief and will greatly benefit their business. And then you don’t hear anything, and in that information vacuum, you are trapped. It becomes difficult to do anything. You can’t make any decisions about staff or even equipment, and importantly you can’t pitch for other business. You don’t know whether you will have capacity.

Pitching is a lengthy process for a client too. It’s a huge amount of work to brief, co-ordinate and appraise agencies –and a lot of effort goes into the process. It’s also a big decision, one which requires and deserves time and attention. However, over the last few years, the time that agencies are being made to wait has grown exponentially. Agencies are being trapped for longer and longer. So the question is this, should there be a time limit put on the process?

Later that day, in double Irish, I heard that she had said yes.

She re-pitched the relationship 4 days later.

Rory

Posted in Advertising, Creative, Interesting thoughts, Rant | Leave a comment

Divine Digital

Digital activity that links with real world activity has been shown to be hugely effective. But linking the Digital world with the Divine…that I’m not so sure of. The Catholic Church has decided to run with it though. They have just approved a new app – “Confessions: A Roman Catholic App”. Now there are plenty of religious apps out there already from Mass to Bibles. But divine forgiveness for two bucks feels a bit too easy. The makers claim that the app should not replace going to confession, but be used more as a sin tracker. I wonder how the parish priest will react when he’s handed an iPad and asked to tab through the list himself?

Chris

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Superbowl snorefest.

This years Superbowl was a bit of a snorefest for me to be honest. Mainly because I slept through it and also because the ads we’re a real let down.

Check them out here.

A lot of very mediocre stuff in there. Given a 60sec spot costs $3million you’d think they’d all be awesome. It’s also starting to get fairly predictable. Doritos get fans to make their ads. The car companies get all patriotic and godaddy.com ( or .co in this case) go for cleavage – and a fair amount of retouching judging by the figure on Joan Rivers!

My favourite is VW ‘The Force’. For two reasons. Firstly, I watched all three original Star Wars movies just last week and reminded myself for the hundredth time how good they are and secondly, I think the insight in it is great. Not a massive ‘this will change the world’ kind of insight but a small ‘I could really see myself doing that’ one. Which are probably a lot more common but no less engaging to the right audience. Plus man those little hands can act!

Patrick

PS. In case you’re wondering I could see myself doing the ‘Dad’ bit……and i’m pretty sure I tried using the force when I was six……teen.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

True Grit

Citigroup have made an interesting fashion prediction in their 2011 Trend Report. Worn-in denim, fringe and gingham prints will be coming to a financial district near you, as everyone hunkers down ‘True Grit’ style to weather the storm. If this is true for New York, I wonder what the True Grit equivalent in Dublin will be? The notion of financial elite shedding the trappings of excess and donning tweed caps and elbow patches is a rather appealing one.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment